• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St.

At Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St., pie-making is an art form steeped in tradition and passion. Located in the heart of Denver, this charming bakery specializes in both sweet and savory pies, offering a diverse menu that caters to every taste. With options like tangy Key Lime Pie and decadent French Silk, customers rave about the flaky, buttery crusts and the delicious fillings that strike a perfect balance of flavor. Committed to sustainability, Legacy uses compostable containers and plastic-free packaging. Dog-friendly and welcoming, it’s a delightful spot for pie lovers, guaranteeing a memorable culinary experience.

Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St.: Reviews & Ratings

Jeffry C.
Jeffry C.

Legacy Pie!!!!! What have you done to me ?!!! Obsessed with this place I dream about the banana pie lol Place should be called Legendary Pie... There was a line out the door but the wait was no longer than 10 mins ... super worth it !!! Staff were sooooo nice and made the experience that much better . Love the store line on the wall, made the process feel a lot more personal. The feel of the place felt very joyous You can either take it to go or you can enjoy it there at the location !! Looked like they had sweet and savory pies ... Will be back again and again

Alyse H.
Alyse H.

While shopping on Tennyson, my sister and I couldn't help but check out this adorable little shop. Everything looked so good, but I opted for the cherry pie. I'm not usually a crust girl, but theirs wasn't too thick and was flaky in all the right places. The cherry filling was tart and not too sweet. I know we'll be returning on my future visits to Denver!

Tabitha B.
Tabitha B.

My new favorite place! Such a cute little pie shop. I got the mixed berry, caramel apple crumble, and the French silk. My favorite is the mixed berry, it's sweet and tart and has juicy strawberries and is just incredibly delicious. The French silk is also incredible. I am excited to return so I can try their savory hand pies :)

Victor B.
Victor B.

Legacy Pie company offers some of the tastiest pies around. Small or large, you can't go wrong. My Sweetheart thoroughly enjoys the French silk and I tend to prefer the caramel apple bourbon.....so yummy. The service is quick, staff always friendly and helpful. The shop is just the right size with a few tables to enjoy your selection on site if you'd like. Only drawback is the parking situation. Fully walkable from the surrounding neighborhood but beware if driving in, especially on a weekend evening. We've yet to try their savory options but may on a future visit.

Marina F.
Marina F.

Their Chicken Pot Pies are Fabulously Delicious. There is a bottom and a top crust that tastes so buttery and the gravy inside with the chicken and vegetables is Delicious. Also, their fruit pies are Incredibly Delicious, as well. I especially like their Key Lime Pies, but all of them are very Delicious l. I also got a Chocolate Chip Cookie tonight and it was the "Best"

Rika M.
Rika M.

I can't seem to get enough of this hand pie shop lately. It was only a few weeks ago when I made a quick stop at this place early in the morning to grab a few savory ones. Today's on a chilly Saturday afternoon, this Sunnyside neighborhood was busy with so many people doing their out and about, street parking was almost impossible. Once I managed to find a spot to park my car several blocks away, I rushed to this place to get me a few of those savory ones to satisfy my mid afternoon hunger. This shop is always clean and adorable. Service is also always good and friendly. The lady behind the counter was very patient with me while I was being indecisive (lol!!) What I got me today were Pork one and the veggie curry one. Like I have tasted several different savory ones in the past the pies were nice and flaky. Dense and yet never oily. What's in the center of each pie was so flavorful. They just simply make the bestest hand pies in town. The remedy to my hunger was instant. These impeccably made hand pies never seem to disappoint me in any way. And they will stay fresh overnight so I'm so looking forward to eating them again tomorrow morning.

Jarred F.
Jarred F.

This is a must if you love real pies that have top notch ingredients. The key lime is off the charts and the people who work there are super friendly people. The shop has fun music and we enjoyed sitting and enjoying our medium sized pie which is perfect for 3-4 people to share.

Kim V.
Kim V.

I wish I could give LPC a million stars. Their savory pies are perfect for keeping in the freezer and heating up for when you need an easy meal. I recently tried their thanksgiving special and it was absolutely delish.

Stephanie R.
Stephanie R.

If you're looking for the best pies you've ever had in your life, they're here at Legacy Pie Co. You may think this is a dramatic statement, but my husband and I love this place. We visited the area for the whole month in January and bought 13 items over the course of that time. We couldn't get enough! Even took a pie on the road-trip with us to go back home. Fast forward to a couple months later and a big move to the state, we had to revisit our favorite pie spot! The staff members are always so warm, welcoming and friendly and the place is impeccably clean. They bake their pies fresh in the back so you know once you step in the door, the aroma is heavenly. There are even frozen pies in the fridge off to the side so you can take and bake them yourself at home for later! The selection is amazing and you can't go wrong with any of the daily and seasonal flavors. The crust is dangerously good - so flakey and buttery! We were able to get our hands on a Strawberry Rhubarb yesterday when we stopped by and I honestly don't have the words to continue talking about how these are the best pies ever. Great to share, but you may not want to.

Emily C.
Emily C.

So good! I'm not typically a huge pie person, but Legacy Pie Co might just change that! We've tried the key lime, mixed berry, and French silk so far. All delicious! The key lime was probably my favorite, followed by mixed berry. Having the smaller sized options is a great way to try different flavors. The staff was super friendly and helpful. I'll definitely be back and can't wait to try some of the other flavors.

Location

Welcome to the delightful world of Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St., where sweet dreams come to life in pie form! Nestled in the heart of Denver at 4000 Tennyson St Suite 100, this charming bakery is a haven for pie lovers seeking both traditional flavors and innovative creations.

What sets Legacy Pie Co. apart? Let's dive into their offerings:

  • Locally-Inspired Flavors: From the tartness of their Key Lime Pie to the decadent creaminess of their French Silk Pie, each bite tells a story of craftsmanship and quality.
  • Gluten-Free Options: With a commitment to inclusivity, Legacy provides gluten-free alternatives for many pies, ensuring that everyone can indulge guilt-free.
  • Sustainability Matters: Their use of compostable containers and plastic-free packaging showcases their dedication to the environment, making each purchase a feel-good choice.
  • Mini Pies for Sharing: Ideal for gatherings, their mini sweet pies elevate any occasion. You can enjoy a burst of flavor with their Mini Tart Cherry or Apple Caramel Crisp, perfect for sharing with friends or family.

The atmosphere in the shop is as warm and inviting as the pies are delicious. As one customer, Alyse H., noted, the crust is "flaky in all the right places," which perfectly complements the tart cherry filling, a must-try for fruit pie aficionados. Jeffry C. expressed his obsession with the Banana Pie, proving that the flavors found here are destined to linger in your dreams.

But it's not just the pies that shine; the staff's friendliness adds an extra layer of joy to the experience. Customers often mention how welcoming the team is, making even a short wait feel worthwhile. As Victor B. puts it, "The service is quick, and the staff always friendly and helpful."

Whether you choose to take your pie to go or savor it in the cozy shop, Legacy Pie Co.- Tennyson St. is a delightful destination for dessert lovers and casual visitors alike. With street parking available and dogs allowed, it’s a great spot to stop by during your stroll in the neighborhood.

Ready to indulge? You can reach them at (303) 635-6748 or simply pop in to experience the legacy of taste that will keep you coming back for more!